President Donald Trump openly criticized Sen. John Cornyn, R-Texas, for blocking his judicial nominee for the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas. Trump told Fox News' "Saturday in America" that Cornyn is doing a "tremendous disservice" by holding up T. Elliot Gaiser, a senior lawyer at the Department of Justice.
Trump asserted that Cornyn's actions stem from "hurt feelings" after the president endorsed Ken Paxton, Cornyn's challenger in the Texas Republican Senate primary. Trump said Cornyn "would have lost by a lot" in that primary contest.
The president warned that blocking Gaiser could result in a "radical left lunatic" filling the judicial seat.
Cornyn confirmed to The Associated Press his intention not to return the "blue slip" for Gaiser. This Senate tradition grants home state senators influence over judicial nominees, effectively allowing them to block appointments by withholding the slip.
In response to Trump's comments, Cornyn posted on X questioning the timing of the nomination. He pointed out that the Dallas judicial seat has been vacant since 2025 and that Trump waited until after the midterms to nominate a candidate.
Cornyn also raised concerns about Gaiser's qualifications, describing him as a "non-Texan with little connection to the Lone Star State" with "no trial court experience." He said Gaiser has not undergone appropriate vetting for a lifetime judicial appointment.
Cornyn emphasized the Senate's constitutional duty of "advice and consent," stating that this responsibility requires proper consultation from the White House. He indicated a willingness to work with the president to fill the seat while the Senate holds a majority.
Cornyn said he has forwarded an "outstanding candidate" to the White House Counsel. This candidate received high ratings from a bipartisan Federal Judicial Evaluation Committee that includes Cornyn and Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas. According to Cornyn, his preferred candidate has already been interviewed by White House Counsel. He noted that only an FBI background check is pending and that authorities "stand ready to do" it "on a timely basis."
