WASHINGTON
North Carolina Republican lawmakers redrew congressional voting maps ahead of the recent election, intending to secure one additional U.S. House seat. The effort instead led to Democrats gaining two seats—a reversal that political scientists call a "dummymander."
State Senator Ralph Hise told a Senate committee last fall that the revamped map aimed to prevent Democratic gains. The new congressional map "should perform to elect 11 Republicans," Hise said.
The plan involved moving six GOP-leaning counties along North Carolina's coast from the 3rd Congressional District into the 1st. Republicans hoped this would help a GOP candidate defeat incumbent Democratic Congressman Don Davis in the 1st, the state's most competitive seat.
To maintain even population across districts, lawmakers moved four "purple counties" into the 3rd District. This diluted the advantage held by incumbent Republican Congressman Greg Murphy.
Raymond Smith, a Democrat, former state legislator, educator and U.S. Army veteran, lived in one of the counties moved into the 3rd District. Smith said he had not considered running for Congress until the new map was finalized. "Certainly piqued our interest," he said of the map changes.
Murphy, whose previous work focused on coastal issues, recognized the gamble immediately. The new map "made us the weakest Republican district in the state," he said. He considered running in the new 1st Congressional District to stay with the coastal counties but ultimately remained in the 3rd.
In November, voters in the 3rd District elected Smith over Murphy by approximately 260 votes. In the 1st, incumbent Democrat Don Davis defeated Republican challenger Laurie Buckhout.
Analysis of vote totals from the shifted counties shows that under the previous map, both Davis and Murphy likely would have won reelection. The redistricting effort produced a net loss of two seats for Republicans in North Carolina.
Ohio saw similar results after Republican-led redistricting. New maps there contributed to voters electing three additional Democrats to Congress.

