BRUSSELS — The European Commission faces accusations of misrepresenting Egypt's compliance with social welfare targets to facilitate the release of €2.5 billion in macro-financial assistance loans. The charges stem from leaked EU documents and data removed from an Egyptian government website.
The allegations relate to a €7.4 billion "comprehensive partnership" deal spanning three years, which European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen promised to Egyptian President Abdel Fatah al-Sisi during a visit to Cairo in 2024. The agreement aimed to strengthen Egypt's economy, reduce migration flows to Europe and stabilize a region affected by the October 7 attacks and the conflict in Gaza.
Central to the controversy are €5 billion in EU "soft" loans with easy repayment terms. Macro-financial assistance funds are typically contingent on recipient countries upholding human rights and democratic principles, though these conditions are often broadly defined. The loans also mandate specific economic reforms from Egypt.
Confidential EU documents indicate the Commission informed lawmakers that Egypt had "broadly fulfilled" and subsequently "fulfilled" two targets requiring an increase in impoverished individuals enrolled in social welfare programs between 2024 and 2026.
However, the data reveals a net reduction of 85,734 households from Egypt's welfare programs, contradicting claims of expanded coverage. The Egyptian government removed beneficiaries rather than increasing enrollment.
Had Egypt expanded its programs in line with the EU's apparent conditions and removed no households, approximately 245,000 households—roughly 909,000 people—would be receiving benefits, according to World Bank data.
Despite the documented net reduction in beneficiaries, the Commission approved two separate "soft" loans totaling €2.5 billion. The leaked documents show the Commission's desire for Egypt to "further expand cash transfer programmes."
The disclosure raises questions about the EU-Egypt relationship at a time when Egyptian authorities face international scrutiny over declining press freedom.
Recent actions include the jailing and alleged torture of six journalists comprising the entire newsroom of the Matsadaash fact-checking and investigative platform. One of Egypt's last independent news outlets was closed last month, and its prominent editor, Lina Attalah, was convicted.
Attalah is appealing her conviction and is scheduled to appear in court this week to challenge other charges, including "publishing false news." She was previously sentenced to a year in prison in absentia for that charge.