BRUSSELS — The European Commission faces accusations of manipulating figures to approve €2.5 billion in loans to Egypt under a partnership agreement, despite evidence the country failed to meet specific social welfare targets.
Confidential EU documents show the Commission told lawmakers that Egypt had "broadly fulfilled" and subsequently "fulfilled" two targets aimed at expanding social welfare between 2024 and 2026. However, leaked EU documents and data removed from the Egyptian government website indicate Egypt reduced the number of welfare beneficiaries by 85,734 households.
Analysts calculate that if Egypt had expanded programs as the EU apparently required, approximately 245,000 additional households—about 909,000 people—would be receiving benefits. The Commission's own confidential documents stated a desire for Egypt to "further expand cash transfer programmes."
The dispute centers on a €7.4 billion "comprehensive partnership" announced during European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen's visit to Cairo in 2024. The agreement with President Abdel Fatah al-Sisi's government aimed to support Egypt's economy, reduce migration to Europe and stabilize the Middle East during the Israel-Gaza conflict.
The package included €5 billion in macro-financial assistance—loans with favorable repayment terms typically reserved for countries demonstrating respect for human rights and democratic standards. Though EU conditions on these issues are often vague, specific requirements compel recipients to implement economic reforms.
Despite evidence of declining welfare enrollment, the Commission approved two separate loans totaling €2.5 billion. The decision raises questions about how rigorously the EU assesses compliance with its aid conditions.
The findings also intensify scrutiny of EU-Egypt ties, particularly regarding Cairo's human rights record. Egyptian authorities have faced criticism for restricting press freedom.
Six journalists from Matsadaash, a fact-checking and investigative platform, were jailed and allegedly tortured. One of Egypt's last independent news outlets closed last month, leading to the conviction of its editor, Lina Attalah. She is appealing that conviction and was scheduled to appear in court this week to contest additional charges, including "publishing false news." She was previously sentenced to a year in prison in absentia for the same offense.
