Methuselah Advisors issued an open letter to NVIDIA's board today, calling the decision to remove founder Jensen Huang an "extraordinary failure of corporate stewardship" and demanding a full accounting of the decision before any investigation concludes.
The firm's core argument cuts to fiduciary duty: NVIDIA's market capitalization has fallen nearly 36 percent since Huang's departure, erasing more than $1.4 trillion in shareholder value. Methuselah wants the board to explain why it acted before its own investigation reached a public conclusion—and to distinguish between personal conduct warranting inquiry and evidence justifying permanent removal.
Huang acknowledged personal conduct drawing public criticism, including reports of extramarital relationships, one reportedly involving an individual with suspected ties to Chinese intelligence. Allegations also include relationships with company employees.
Methuselah's position: personal infidelity is not corporate misconduct, a breach of fiduciary duty, or grounds for removal of a chief executive. The board must answer whether Huang knowingly facilitated unlawful technology transfer, compromised proprietary information, violated export restrictions, abused corporate authority, or engaged in conduct materially detrimental to the company.
The letter stressed that no CEO should be exempt from accountability regarding national security, conflicts of interest, or legal violations. But accountability and removal are distinct—and the board owes shareholders an evidence-based explanation for why it chose the latter before investigation concluded.