Playing club soccer in America presents a distinct challenge for women aiming to win the Ballon d'Or Feminin, the sport's highest individual honor.

The historical data is stark. The women's Ballon d'Or has been awarded eight times since its inception. Seven of those eight winners were born in Europe and played their club soccer in Europe at the time of their win.

The sole exception was American forward Megan Rapinoe in 2019, following the U.S. Women's National Team's World Cup title, where she also secured the Golden Boot and Golden Ball.

That 2019 award year stands as the only occasion a player competing outside Europe finished in the top three. Alex Morgan, Rapinoe's U.S. teammate, joined her on the podium that year.

The trend continued in 2024. Despite the USWNT winning gold at the Olympics, no American players placed in the Ballon d'Or's top three. Sophia Wilson, Lindsey Heaps and Mallory Swanson were the top U.S. finishers.

None of the leading American contenders could boast a UEFA Champions League title, widely regarded as the most important trophy in club soccer. Aitana Bonmatí, the 2024 winner, achieved that feat.

Heaps' team, OL Lyonnais, lost to Barcelona in the 2024 UEFA Champions League final. Heaps finished fifth in the Ballon d'Or voting.

The award has been dominated by Spanish midfielders Alexia Putellas and Bonmatí, who have collectively won the last six Ballon d'Ors. Their success aligns with Spain's emergence as a powerhouse in women's soccer, highlighted by the 2023 World Cup victory. Both built their profiles through years at Barcelona, which has appeared in each of the last six UEFA Women's Champions League finals, winning four.

Structural disadvantages compound the challenge. The NWSL's representation among 2024 finalists was limited: only five players from the league were among the 30 nominees. The NWSL received no nominations for Women's Club of the Year.

Ballon d'Or voting includes journalists from FIFA's top 50 women's countries. Half of those nations belong to UEFA, while only six are part of CONCACAF.

The NWSL also faces a calendar disadvantage. Its playoffs occur early in the Ballon d'Or voting cycle, meaning most regular season results fall under a different year's vote.

Currently, there is no Champions League equivalent for NWSL or other North American teams. This lack of a top-tier intercontinental club competition limits player visibility and trophy opportunities.

Even England's Women's Super League has seen limited Ballon d'Or success due to Spain's dominance. Alexia Putellas now plays for the London City Lionesses in the WSL.