BRUSSELS — The European Commission faces accusations of manipulating figures to facilitate the release of funds to Egypt under a €7.4 billion partnership deal announced by European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen during a 2024 visit to Cairo.
The controversy centers on €5 billion in EU "soft" loans, which offer favorable repayment terms and are designated as macro-financial assistance. Such assistance is typically contingent on recipient countries upholding human rights and democratic principles, alongside specific economic reform requirements.
Confidential documents from the Commission provided to EU lawmakers claimed Egypt had "broadly fulfilled" and subsequently "fulfilled" two targets mandating an increase in the number of impoverished individuals enrolled in social welfare programs between 2024 and 2026.
However, separate data sources—including leaked EU documents and information removed from an Egyptian government website—contradict these claims. The data indicates a net reduction of 85,734 households from Egypt's welfare programs, rather than the required expansion of coverage.
If Egypt had expanded the programs in line with the EU's apparent conditions without removing any households, approximately 245,000 households, equivalent to about 909,000 people, would have been receiving these benefits, according to calculations using World Bank data.
Despite the documented net reduction in beneficiaries, the Commission approved two separate soft loans collectively amounting to €2.5 billion.
The disclosure highlights broader concerns regarding the EU-Egypt relationship, particularly as Egyptian authorities face heightened scrutiny over diminishing press freedom. Six journalists from Matsadaash, a fact-checking and investigative platform, have been jailed and allegedly tortured.
One of Egypt's last independent news outlets was closed last month, and its prominent editor, Lina Attalah, was convicted. Attalah is appealing her conviction and is scheduled to appear in court this week to challenge other charges, including "publishing false news," for which she received a one-year prison sentence in absentia.